10-30-2026, 06:20 PM
Thanks Jared, Randalf and Misha for the thought-provoking points you've raised.
I accept that the IFAB's preface to their rules is very heavily rhetorical, but I think we disagree on what goal the rhetoric serves. The preface is not a defence of the specific rules of Association Football,¹ but rather a defence of the IFAB (as Misha puts it) 'tighten[ing] the cloud of football games' which can be played. While a cynic might argue this is simply the IFAB cementing the authority of their rules (and therefore cementing their power over the sport), I think they're making a fascinating ontological claim: one of the essential properties of football (as we understand the game today) is its universality, its ability to be the 'World's Game.' In other words, if we lived in an alternate universe where every town and village had their own rules for football, a hypothetical town which by coincidence ended up with the modern Association Football rules still wouldn't be 'playing the same game'.² And, as strange as their claim sounds, I think I agree with the IFAB here. There are many games where the broader culture surrounding the game strongly affects the experience of play. The Reddit April Fool's day games are frequently examples of this, where follow-up websites replicating the rules and mechanics often fail to recreate the experience of playing the original. Although I don't know much about it, from the way the internet talks about Sam's Over/Under game, it feels like it may fall into this category too.
¹ I also disagree that any such defence is necessarily rhetorical. You could investigate a claim like 'The rules of Association Football are more fun than the Cambridge Rules' through a non-rhetorical lens, e.g. a sociological lens might involve observing many games of each and interviewing players on their experiences (or giving them wearable EEGs while they played, or putting them in an MRI machine and asking them to think about their experiences of each game), while a historical lens could examine play reports of Cambridge Rules football tournaments etc. Of course, that's not to say that such investigations can't be used to make rhetorical arguments; I'm simply saying they aren't only useful rhetorically.
² Randalf provided a good critique of the idea of 'playing the same game,' which I agree is at the heart of this matter. The more precise claim here is that the fame of the sport fundamentally changes the experience of play. It's why many people play football wearing shirts with Lionel Messi's name and number on the back, and why they run around trying to whip up cheers from an imaginary crowd after scoring a goal during the school lunchtime game. It would feel like (and therefore be) a totally different game if your village were the only place this game existed.
I accept that the IFAB's preface to their rules is very heavily rhetorical, but I think we disagree on what goal the rhetoric serves. The preface is not a defence of the specific rules of Association Football,¹ but rather a defence of the IFAB (as Misha puts it) 'tighten[ing] the cloud of football games' which can be played. While a cynic might argue this is simply the IFAB cementing the authority of their rules (and therefore cementing their power over the sport), I think they're making a fascinating ontological claim: one of the essential properties of football (as we understand the game today) is its universality, its ability to be the 'World's Game.' In other words, if we lived in an alternate universe where every town and village had their own rules for football, a hypothetical town which by coincidence ended up with the modern Association Football rules still wouldn't be 'playing the same game'.² And, as strange as their claim sounds, I think I agree with the IFAB here. There are many games where the broader culture surrounding the game strongly affects the experience of play. The Reddit April Fool's day games are frequently examples of this, where follow-up websites replicating the rules and mechanics often fail to recreate the experience of playing the original. Although I don't know much about it, from the way the internet talks about Sam's Over/Under game, it feels like it may fall into this category too.
¹ I also disagree that any such defence is necessarily rhetorical. You could investigate a claim like 'The rules of Association Football are more fun than the Cambridge Rules' through a non-rhetorical lens, e.g. a sociological lens might involve observing many games of each and interviewing players on their experiences (or giving them wearable EEGs while they played, or putting them in an MRI machine and asking them to think about their experiences of each game), while a historical lens could examine play reports of Cambridge Rules football tournaments etc. Of course, that's not to say that such investigations can't be used to make rhetorical arguments; I'm simply saying they aren't only useful rhetorically.
² Randalf provided a good critique of the idea of 'playing the same game,' which I agree is at the heart of this matter. The more precise claim here is that the fame of the sport fundamentally changes the experience of play. It's why many people play football wearing shirts with Lionel Messi's name and number on the back, and why they run around trying to whip up cheers from an imaginary crowd after scoring a goal during the school lunchtime game. It would feel like (and therefore be) a totally different game if your village were the only place this game existed.

