Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Game Texts as Texts
#11
Quote:Jared: Yeah absolutely, but I wouldn't describe this process as "non-rhetorical" at all. On the contrary, by presenting an instance (or set of instances) of play as representative of "correct" play, we are creating a rhetorical framework for understanding play. (And, incidentally, I'd characterize this process as based in ethos-building, insofar as it places personal experience as precisely the practical factor in advocating for a particular kind of play.) This is already a thing that some game books do, obliquely at least, in the form of "examples of play," which can have myriad purposes but this is decidedly one imo.

I would argue that the difference lies in intent. Presenting the rules or method of play, as the demonstrator understands them, does not necessarily create an intent to demonstrate "correct" play. Furthermore, demonstrative play of this kind, even when presenting "correct" play, is not necessarily rhetorical in that there is no intent to persuade, per se. Persuasion in this regard implies an actuality or illusion of choice, and with limited knowledge there simply is no choice outside of denying the existence of the game entirely.

To clarify, when I engage in physical play with my toddler, I am informing the development of their sense of physical and social boundaries, the "rules", in regards to pain, exertion, communication, expression, etc. While my "sense" of those parameters will inform the development of their own, I have no "intent to persuade" in that regard. That is, I'm not teaching them lessons about pain boundaries by intentionally causing pain. Their sense development occurs through engagement and "accident". Crucially, without this type of play, a child's "sense" of physical and social boundaries is often misaligned or underdeveloped, but only from an outside perspective. Their own experience of their sense does not feel "incomplete".

When learning to play football for the first time in a child-like setting, the sense of the structure of play is developed in a similar "trial-by-error" fashion. And this form of ad hoc, demonstrative learning exists outside the structure of rhetoric. It does not persuade one to play in a "correct" way, it simply demonstrates "the way" to play, becoming the de facto, singular standard through simple ignorance of any alternative. Therefore it cannot be persuasive, only informative.

When I was first introduced to Dungeons & Dragons it was by a friend who had been given the 3E Monster Manual for Christmas. I was already a monster and mythology obsessed kid, so I was immediately entranced. When I asked him how to play the game, he said that you choose which monster you want to be and then everyone battles with their chosen monsters until there's a winner. And we played that way for a few weeks, until I finally got my hands on the Player's Handbook and had to tell my friend how horribly misinformed he had been.

Now, as awesome as a Pokemon/Mortal Kombat/battle royale-style mash-up with D&D monsters sounds, for those brief few weeks that was what D&D was to me. My friend had no intent outside of showing me what he knew to be "the way" to play the game, and lacking any specific knowledge of my own, I had no choice but to either accept his information as true, or brand him as liar and deny that such a game existed at all, which is notably hard to do with the evidence of a game in my hand, even if that evidence later proved to be something else entirely.

Obviously these are specific cases, and perhaps a rhetorical framework as Jared described is the more common way that people learn new games, but my intent was to argue against "universals".
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)