Welcome, Guest
You have to register before you can post on our site.

Username
  

Password
  





Search Forums

(Advanced Search)

Forum Statistics
» Members: 145
» Latest member: Andrew736
» Forum threads: 32
» Forum posts: 188

Full Statistics

Online Users
There are currently 11 online users.
» 0 Member(s) | 11 Guest(s)

Latest Threads
When to Finish a Monopoly...
Forum: Episode Discussion
Last Post: Andrew736
Yesterday, 07:42 AM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 15
Why COD MW4 Players Targe...
Forum: Episode Discussion
Last Post: Andrew736
Yesterday, 07:28 AM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 15
Diablo 4 Physical Resista...
Forum: Episode Discussion
Last Post: Andrew736
Yesterday, 07:15 AM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 17
U4GM Explores the GTA 6 A...
Forum: Episode Discussion
Last Post: Andrew736
Yesterday, 07:03 AM
» Replies: 0
» Views: 16
Fictional modern day sett...
Forum: RPG Discussion
Last Post: Dr_Colossus
11-20-2026, 09:24 PM
» Replies: 4
» Views: 60
Introductions
Forum: Off Topic
Last Post: iknowadamseats
11-17-2026, 05:53 PM
» Replies: 25
» Views: 3,145
Forum Book Club?
Forum: Off Topic
Last Post: Dr_Colossus
11-13-2026, 12:30 PM
» Replies: 1
» Views: 304
Episode 27: The Invisible...
Forum: Episode Discussion
Last Post: Dr_Colossus
11-12-2026, 08:50 PM
» Replies: 22
» Views: 2,681
Ep: 33 Spine
Forum: Episode Discussion
Last Post: couragemouse
11-10-2026, 11:07 PM
» Replies: 1
» Views: 110
Ethos, Pathos, Logos: Gam...
Forum: Discourse & Gossip
Last Post: Randalf the Gray
11-01-2026, 11:16 PM
» Replies: 10
» Views: 699

 
  Troupe Play and Sandbox Campaigns
Posted by: sam_the_bold - 09-08-2026, 01:11 AM - Forum: RPG Discussion - Replies (13)

Something I've been rotating in my mind is the role of troupe play in big sandbox campaigns. I say "troupe play" in a very broad sense: really, I just mean "you don't always have the same characters in the party each session." And I've realized that, with relatively few exceptions, pretty much all of the big long sandbox campaigns I've run have ended up involving troupe play or something much like it:

  • I've run West Marches and open tables, for both overland crawls and dungeons, usually with a roster of ten to twenty players or so. 
  • In my Seas of Sand, Mothership, and Wolves Upon the Coast campaigns, there have been crews aboard the ship(s), which provide an easy list of extra NPCs who can go on adventures or serve as replacement PCs. 
  • In my long-running Heresy campaign, we ended up with four "main PCs," the primary heroes of the campaign and the leaders of their rebel heresy, and then ten-ish "minions," who got substituted in and out on various adventures. I think by the end of the game, the average adventuring party had like one-and-a-half main PCs. 
What I've noticed is that in each of these cases, troupe play facilitates the sandbox: it means that characters can die without ending the main quest, making it easier to have huge terrifying monsters and threats, and it means there is a lot more flexibility in team composition for problem-solving, which expands the range of flavors of problems you can set up for players to face. 

Likewise, while this isn't explicitly tied to troupe play, I find two common knock-on effects of troupe play are 1) you need a home base or other place to leave your dudes that aren't out on an adventure, and 2) that you need downtime activities for those homebound dudes to do "off-screen." And both of those together encourage a much larger, richer field of play. (As a tangent, watching the Quinns Quest video about Stonetop, I was struck by how much of his praise focused on the longevity of the game and the effect of giving players a home base situated in the world—both things that Stonetop does by default, true, but also don't seem terribly unique.)

These elements combined—a wide range of dangers and threats, a home base, and prominent downtime—all feel like they really enable a proper sandbox game. One that's focused not just on "where your party is traveling at this exact moment," but one that exists and persists within a wider, broader world. And so now I'm wondering, for whatever future big sandbox campaign games I run and big sandbox campaign projects I make, how I can best support and enable and encourage troupe play. 

Any good ideas?

Print this item

  The greatest brainstorming document of all time.
Posted by: AmICoolYet? - 09-07-2026, 08:13 PM - Forum: RPG Discussion - Replies (18)

People are saying that Mythic Bastionland is the greatest brainstorming doc of all time. Game wise its so loose to not have any super clear or coherent systems. But all of the entries are so evocative, and exiting to read, that I want to run them and put them in my games, even if I am not playing Bastionalnd. When I open the book, I'm not actually looking to play game, I am looking for all the cool monsters that Mr. McDowell came up with so I can steal them for games I run other systems.

Print this item

  TTRPG Book Club, 09.10.26
Posted by: sam_the_bold - 09-07-2026, 07:58 PM - Forum: New York City - Replies (3)

This has already gone up on the socials, but if you're in the city and want to attend our RPG book club, it's this Thursday at 7:00 p.m. at boshi's place (the premier independent games/arts space) in East Williamsburg! We're reading Tomb of a Thousand Doors, the Mausritter anthology megadungeon. We'd love to see you there! 

We as the book club decide on our next book at the end of each club meeting, so I'll be sure to update this thread once we decide. 

[Image: bafkreice4a7wqu662zio6sofootsqu72omcfgid...kxaal7fx5u]

Print this item

  GREATEST CITY IN DA WORLD BABY
Posted by: riles - 09-07-2026, 05:30 PM - Forum: New York City - Replies (2)

LOVE ZOHRAN

LOVE DA METS

SIMPLE AS



Attached Files
.jpg   FY24_New-York_NY_0346_2000px-750x600.jpg (Size: 159.61 KB / Downloads: 2)
Print this item

  A New Forum Arises...
Posted by: sam_the_bold - 09-07-2026, 05:18 PM - Forum: Discourse & Gossip - Replies (4)

Holy moly gamers, it's a forum! Take that, Discord, you're passé! 

It's true we certainly aren't the first. Nor are we even really the first new-age revival forum—those honors go to the Gauntlet, and more recently Paper Cult Club—but it is exciting! I can't think of any other RPG podcasts off the dome that have opted for a forum, rather than a Discord server or other chatroom. 

We'll see how it goes! I'm excited!

Print this item

  Forum Philosophy
Posted by: sam_the_bold - 09-07-2026, 02:00 AM - Forum: Rules & Announcements - No Replies

Forum Philosophy

  1. Do the reading. Research is always valuable! Respect and appreciate those who have taken the time to do their homework. (And share what you’ve been reading so we can read it, too!)

  2. Learn from disagreement. We are all going to disagree with each other, often. If we are in total agreement, something has gone awry! Skepticism, critique, and close examination are a gift: it means your peers are reading what you wrote with earnest intent.

  3. Try on new viewpoints. Take a beat to play the Devil’s advocate (though be clear when you do). Earnestly consider the arguments others make, and think through the ramifications they pose.

  4. It’s cool to flippantly disregard the established orthodoxy (and don’t let anyone tell you it isn’t), but only when you can actually back that disregard up with understanding. If you pooh-pooh the existing standards only to end up parroting the same arguments in a new context, you’ve failed in both directions.

  5. Read more than you write. Write often. If you have a big long complicated argument or essay with many parts, consider hosting it elsewhere, like a blog, then linking it here for us to discuss.

These ideas, as with the forum itself, may well change over time.

Print this item

  Forum Rules
Posted by: sam_the_bold - 09-07-2026, 01:58 AM - Forum: Rules & Announcements - No Replies

Forum Rules

  1. Be kind. Don’t be a jerk. Learn to disagree with others’ ideas while still caring for them as people. Speak and act in good faith.

  2. Help the newbies. Discussion can get pretty in the weeds, especially without past context, so take a second to help show more recent members the ropes. Link the old blogposts, readings, and episodes.

  3. No bigotry. No AI. No spam. Don’t platform or support bigots, fascists, or creeps.

  4. Employ content warnings around heavier or less-comfortable topics. They’re fine to talk about, but discussions need to be opt-in. Tag your NSFW stuff accordingly. 

  5. If you want to promote your projects for money or clicks, put it in self-promo thread. If you want to chat about a project you’re working on or a game you ran or something else actively in-progress, go ahead. 

In general, we as moderators try to assume ignorance before malice, but have patience for neither malice nor deliberate ignorance. Follow the rules and learn from your mistakes or catch a ban. 

At some point in the future, we might update these rules.

Print this item

  Self-Promotions!
Posted by: sam_the_bold - 09-07-2026, 01:53 AM - Forum: RPG Discussion - Replies (3)

If you want to promote a project for money or clicks, do it here! We'll take down self-promos elsewhere on the forum.

Print this item

Information Introductions
Posted by: HawkCohenDC - 09-05-2026, 04:28 PM - Forum: Off Topic - Replies (25)

A classic tradition of BBS and forum spaces (and even discords) is introductions! It doesn’t need to be a lot but it’s good to have a place to look people up and get and idea of them. So in that spirit:

1. Who are you?
2. Got any pets?
3. What are you reading lately?
4. What are you playing lately?


I’m Hawk.

No pets, sadly.

Lately I’ve been reading Mason & Dixon by Thomas Pynchon.

Lately I’ve been playing OSE, Delving Deeper and Delta Green.

Print this item

  Ep 26: the black wyrm of Brandonsford
Posted by: JimMonsoon - 09-05-2026, 01:23 PM - Forum: Episode Discussion - Replies (14)

Walid it’s faun vs fawn


Also you guys should get Beau Rancourt onto the podcast (edit: or just read and respond to his work). I don’t agree with all his tuff, but he has very strong opinions on adventure writing and puts in the work for some very detailed critiques. He discusses this module in depth on his blog.

Print this item